top of page

Pros and Cons of Carbon Leasing

Graphic of a scale with a black carbon cloud on the right and a green fan on the left with the earth in the middle

Carbon leasing occurs when landowners rent their land to organizations or companies. These organizations or companies aim to create carbon credits. They achieve this by engaging in activities that either store carbon or reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Carbon leasing is an emerging concept that has been gaining attention in the world of environmental conservation and clean energy.

Landowners are paid to take care of their land to make sure carbon is being stored. Storing more carbon dioxide helps reduce greenhouse gasses. It’s a strategy that aims to combat climate change by harnessing the power of nature. While this concept can have potential benefits for landowners, it also comes with its own set of drawbacks.

Land professionals with clients interested in leasing their property for a carbon lease should know the available options. There are many different carbon credit types available to landowners, some of which can be state specific. Sequestering carbon is one type of carbon opportunity that landowners can participate in if they had oil and gas wells drilled on their property.

Land professionals can use LandGate’s LandApp tool to help their clients determine their property's estimated value for carbon credits. For $10 per month, LandApp comes with nationwide ownership information, custom map creation tools, and extensive property data & analytics to help inform clients of the highest and best use for their property.

Pros of Carbon Leasing

Landowners that have large amounts of acreage with trees can benefit the most from leasing for carbon credits. As a land expert, it's crucial to inform clients about carbon leasing requirements and the possible advantages.

  • Additional Revenue Stream: Landowners can generate additional income by leasing their land for carbon credits. This can provide a stable and diversified income source, especially for rural or agricultural land that might not be as profitable through traditional means.

    • Leasing land for carbon doesn’t require the property to be altered in any way besides making sure that the trees are not cut down.

    • Landowners are able to continue using their land for other purposes as long as it doesn’t interfere with the trees.

  • Environmental Stewardship: Carbon leasing allows landowners to contribute to environmental sustainability by facilitating activities that promote carbon sequestration or emissions reduction. This can enhance a landowner's reputation as an environmentally responsible steward.

  • Long-Term Contracts: Carbon leasing agreements often involve long-term contracts, providing landowners with a predictable income stream over several years, which can help with financial planning and stability.

    • These carbon leases can range between 5 years to 100 years depending on the carbon developer themselves, and what is negotiated. Land professionals can assist their clients during the negotiation process to make sure their clients are getting the best deal.

  • Access to Funding and Resources: Many carbon offset projects require initial investments for activities such as reforestation, afforestation, or sustainable farming practices. Through carbon leasing, landowners can access funding, technical expertise, and resources from the leasing companies.

Cons of Carbon Leasing

Carbon leasing is still a new market that is continuing to grow in the United States, so at the moment, the carbon market can be a bit confusing to landowners and land professionals. It is very important to stay up to date with the changing market for carbon! Since it is still new, change is evident but the goal of reducing carbon emissions is still top priority.

  • Complexity and Administrative Burden: Carbon credit projects can involve complex calculations, monitoring, reporting, and verification processes to ensure that the promised carbon sequestration or emissions reduction is occurring. Landowners may need to deal with administrative tasks that they are not familiar with.

  • Uncertain Carbon Credit Prices: The market for carbon credits can be volatile, and the price of carbon credits can fluctuate over time. This uncertainty can impact the financial returns for landowners, making it challenging to accurately predict the long-term value of their leasing agreement.

  • Land Use Restrictions: Depending on the carbon offset project, landowners might face restrictions on how they can use their land during the leasing period. For instance, they might need to refrain from certain land management practices that could reduce the effectiveness of the carbon sequestration efforts.

  • Long Return on Investment: Some carbon offset projects, such as reforestation, can take years or even decades to show significant carbon sequestration results. Landowners might need to wait for an extended period before seeing substantial financial returns on their carbon leasing investment.

  • Verification Costs: The process of verifying and certifying carbon offset projects can incur additional costs. These costs might eat into the revenue generated from carbon leasing agreements, affecting the overall profitability for landowners.

  • Market and Regulatory Risks: Changes in regulations, policies, or market dynamics can impact the demand for carbon credits and affect the financial viability of carbon leasing agreements.

Carbon credit leasing offers landowners the opportunity to not only generate additional revenue but also become environmental stewards. By leasing their land for carbon credits, landowners can contribute to carbon sequestration and emissions reduction efforts, supporting decarbonization initiatives and improving their reputation. The long-term contracts associated with carbon leasing provide stable income streams and access to funding and resources for projects such as reforestation and sustainable land management. Carbon credit leasing presents a valuable avenue for landowners to align financial gains with environmental responsibility. Land professionals can help facilitate these leases for their clients and, with the use of LandApp, get better offers for their clients.


bottom of page